Keeping it in a shared space rather than the bedroom is the most practical line in this, and it's the same rule I'd give for any device with a microphone. Before buying, I'd check three things: whether it works without creating an account, where recordings are stored and for how long, and whether you can delete them. If the company can't answer those clearly, that's your answer. The same three questions work for small businesses buying smart speakers or cameras for the office.
Matt - those are great observations. I know you are making the best observations possible. Great job!
For those of you reading along, companies that say they delete things... generally don't. You just can't trust them, I'm afraid, and there are not any watchdog orgs OR governments that have any oversight over this at all. It's the complete wild west and you cannot trust anyone. If it connects to the Internet in any way, it's suspect. That includes your phone, your television, your coffee maker, your thermostat, etc. There is no safety anywhere.
I'm so glad you wrote, Matt, and I'm not trying to get YOU to understand this - the general public is completely in the dark about the lack of oversight.
Thanks Billy, and that's a fair point. That's why I'd lean towards toys that work fully offline, because the safest recording is the one that never leaves the house.
I'll leave the CEOs to explain themselves. For parents the practical test is simple: if the toy needs an account and the cloud to work, find out what it records and where that goes.
Keeping it in a shared space rather than the bedroom is the most practical line in this, and it's the same rule I'd give for any device with a microphone. Before buying, I'd check three things: whether it works without creating an account, where recordings are stored and for how long, and whether you can delete them. If the company can't answer those clearly, that's your answer. The same three questions work for small businesses buying smart speakers or cameras for the office.
Great additional above Matt ty!
Cheers Dale, it was a really useful guide for parents.
Thankyou mate appreciate it
Matt - those are great observations. I know you are making the best observations possible. Great job!
For those of you reading along, companies that say they delete things... generally don't. You just can't trust them, I'm afraid, and there are not any watchdog orgs OR governments that have any oversight over this at all. It's the complete wild west and you cannot trust anyone. If it connects to the Internet in any way, it's suspect. That includes your phone, your television, your coffee maker, your thermostat, etc. There is no safety anywhere.
I'm so glad you wrote, Matt, and I'm not trying to get YOU to understand this - the general public is completely in the dark about the lack of oversight.
Thanks Billy, and that's a fair point. That's why I'd lean towards toys that work fully offline, because the safest recording is the one that never leaves the house.
You got that right! I'm afraid for parents that don't realize they are handing their children to the machine so they can be guinea pigs.
You don't see silicon valley CEOs pushing this stuff on their children - why is that? Matt knows. :)
Thats the real litmus test when they stop their own children using it.
I'll leave the CEOs to explain themselves. For parents the practical test is simple: if the toy needs an account and the cloud to work, find out what it records and where that goes.
As a parent and educator, this scares me more than horror movies.
💯