Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sarah T's avatar

Argh, I just wrote a long comment about the work I'm doing with kids on the young person's survey at the moment and, ironically, it timed out. It's a fully, ethics committee approved piece of research, on the way that the questions are being asked. I'm working with 9-21 year olds and...they have concerns (all the way through from the 9 year olds up to the 21 year olds!!). I have concerns! I have a RAFT of tips for parents who might want to help their kids fill in the young person's survey; would it be helpful for me to write them up somewhere?

In short, though, what I am seeing from the research so far (which, to the point about ByteDance, has also included the voices of Chinese students towards the top of the age range) -- there is a real concern that the way the questions are structured do not allow for young people to give the answers they want to. There is no option to offer alternative policy options (e.g. why 16? why not 14, 13 or not at all? And why not holistic regulations? -- adults get to answer this). The survey is too long, and most kids so far have suggested they'd zone out (indeed there are no attention check questions, which is horrific survey design in something that too me -- a fully fledged expert adult -- 40 minutes to go through). They get asked counterfactual questions ("what would you be doing if you weren't on social media?"), impossible to answer questions ("how does social media makes you feel?" -- as a multiple choice question with no option to explain further), and free text questions with only two lines visible to type in -- and no prior warning of what the question is, or explanation as to whether the screen will time out. Bluntly, too, they are quite angry that something they've had access to, and built their lives around will just be taken away. Or, rather, that they know it will be "taken away"; they know that a ban is nonsense in terms of changing anything. And so it makes them angry that this will be the policy solution that stops more wide ranging change.

It's a bit of a mess. That's not to say that parents shouldn't support their kids in answering the survey. But I do want them to help their kids understand the extreme limitations of the way they're being asked about something incredibly important to them...

No posts

Ready for more?